REVIEW OF PAPER FOR JOURNAL OF KONES

Paper Number:

Paper Title:

(Please write: yes or not, grade from 1 (marginal) to 10 (excellent), and fill in A, B and C items in all boxes)
According to the best of your knowledge, was previously essence of the paper published: yes/no

1. Data quality and propriety of research techniques of the paper: (1-10)

2. Is the paper professionally novel, innovative, or a creative study: (1-10)

3. Does the paper distinguish professional integrity, refer to earlier works, avoid commercialism
and advertisement; are data objective and correct: (1-10)

4. Quality of presentation (language, composition, graphics): (1-10)

5. Relevance of conclusions: (1-10)

6. Is the paper coincident with literal requirements: yes/no

7. Does the paper distinguish values concerning long-term reference: yes/no

8. Were Author's other papers cited in the last two years: yes/no

9. Will the paper be cited by other Authors in the next two years: yes/no

10. Do you recommend the paper for printing in Journal of KONES:

without terms: yes/no

after corrections: yes/no

A. Detailed remarks:

B. Strong aspects of the paper:

C. Poor aspects of the paper:

Title, First Name and Surname of Reviewer, Date, Signature

Note: For the fulfilment boxes, please press the button "Switch over design of blank forms" in „Drawing kit of formants”

Andrzej Wiśniewski

2013-07-17

Instytut Lotnictwa BK